Labour sees Reform voters as its own—but deeply frustrated
In a striking admission after a disappointing local election night, Labour’s political director acknowledged that many Reform UK supporters “are our people,” but are simply “pissed off” with Sir Keir Starmer’s government. This candid confession followed significant losses for Labour in council by-elections and a high-profile defeat in Runcorn and Helsby—previously one of the party’s safest seats.
Disastrous local results expose underlying discontent
Labour returned just 98 councillors on election night, a net loss of 187 seats compared to 2021. The traditional heartlands showed signs of erosion:
- Runcorn & Helsby by-election: Once comfortably held by Labour, this seat swung to Reform UK, a clear warning that core voters stayed at home or switched allegiance.
- Low turnout among Labour voters: Private polling revealed habitual Labour supporters chose not to vote, even as Reform UK mobilised non-voters effectively.
- Geographic spread: Losses were not confined to one region—counties and metropolitan boroughs alike saw unexpected swings.
These results underline a potent mix of apathy and anger brewing within traditional Labour demographics.
Inside Labour’s private polling: the rise of “angry” Reform supporters
During a strategy meeting convened by Claire Reynolds, MPs reviewed fresh internal data pointing to two key trends:
- Mobilisation of non-voters: Reform campaigns in areas like Runcorn succeeded in engaging people who hadn’t cast a ballot in years, offsetting Labour’s weaker ground game.
- Issue priorities: While immigration was high on voters’ agendas, it was not the sole concern—cost-of-living pressures, healthcare waits and general frustration with “broken promises” featured strongly.
Reynolds stressed that these voters are not inherently right-wing extremists; rather, they feel neglected and disillusioned by successive governments, including Labour’s own.
Why “pissed off” is the new battleground
Reynolds’ choice of words—Labour’s “people” but “pissed off”—reveals a shift in political strategy. No longer framing Reform supporters as alien or beyond persuasion, Labour now sees them as part of its coalition that drifted away:
- Anger at unfulfilled promises: Voters feel the government has failed on visible issues: potholes, hospital waiting times and local service cuts.
- Economic hardship: Spike in household bills, stagnant wages and rising mortgage costs have left many feeling abandoned.
- Distrust of elites: A perception that both major parties are out of touch with everyday concerns, driving protest votes.
This narrative marks a departure from demonising Reform supporters and instead positions Labour as the remedy for widespread frustration.
Starmer’s challenge: “go further and faster”
Downing Street insiders say Sir Keir Starmer is determined to “go further and faster” on delivery, to pre-empt the anger that drove voters toward Reform. Key areas under review include:
- Immigration policy: Despite a high-profile crackdown, polls suggest tougher rhetoric alone won’t win back all swing voters.
- Cost-of-living support: Expanding targeted measures for low-income families, pensioners and key workers.
- Public services: Accelerating hospital and school building programmes, plus restoring local authority funding.
- Communications overhaul: Ensuring policy wins reach the public with empathy and emotional resonance.
Labour insiders stress that narrative matters—outlining clear values, fresh policies and tangible improvements will be vital.
Labour’s vision “a work in progress”
In frank remarks picked up by backbenchers, Reynolds admitted that beneath the surface, Labour’s long-term vision remains “a work in progress.” She urged MPs to articulate “whose side we’re on” and what Britain under Labour will look like in everyday life. This call for clarity reflects wider concerns:
- Policy focus: Too many initiatives risk appearing reactive rather than part of a coherent programme.
- Emotional connection: Voters need to feel that Labour genuinely understands and shares their struggles.
- Innovative solutions: Beyond tax cuts or spend pledges, creative ideas—affordable housing, green jobs and local investment—must take centre stage.
With Reform UK on the rise, Labour faces a fresh battleground for the centre-ground vote.
Looking ahead: Reform as the “main opposition”
Reynolds warned MPs to expect Reform UK as the “major opposition” at the next general election. While the Conservatives are “injured,” Reform’s growing appeal among disaffected voters poses a new threat. Labour strategists are now:
- Monitoring grassroots sentiment in former heartlands.
- Crafting localised messaging to recapture non-voters.
- Prioritising community engagement to rebuild trust.
The task is clear: Labour must prove it can heal the “pissed off” feeling among its own supporters, or risk losing more ground to Nigel Farage’s party.